The answer to your question concerning these two carpe diem poems is probably a matter of opinion, and probably is determined by the values and ideas a reader brings to the poems.
Marvell wants to sleep with his lover. Herrick is giving advice to women to marry while they are young so they can find good matches or avoid not finding a match at all.
I think which poem is seen as more successfully persuasive depends on what one thinks of sex and marriage. Certainly, a woman absolutely against sex outside of marriage would probably not be persuaded by Marvell's rationalizations, for instance.
At the same time, one should remember that these metaphysical poets, as we call them today, are having fun with their poems. The style and the stretched metaphors and unusual imagery are humorous and entertaining. I mean, really, how serious are we supposed to take "vegetable love"?
No comments:
Post a Comment